Chicago may not be known for its seafood, but that doesn't mean the city can't offer a great lobster roll. With so many options to choose from, it can be hard to know where to start.
Whether you're a local or a tourist, you'll want to make sure you're getting the best lobster roll in town.
There's nothing quite like a fresh, succulent lobster roll on a hot summer day. This New England classic has made its way to Chicago and has become a staple on many restaurant menus.
But not all lobster rolls are created equal. Some are too heavy on the mayo, while others skimp on the lobster meat. That's why we've scoured the city to find the best places to get your lobster roll fix.
From classic renditions to unique twists, we've got you covered. Whether you're looking for a fancy restaurant or a casual seafood shack, we've found something for everyone.
So, get ready to indulge in buttery lobster meat, toasted buns, and all the fixings that make a perfect lobster roll.
1. Joe's Seafood
Joe's Seafood is a must-visit for lobster roll lovers. The restaurant serves upmarket American fare and seafood dishes in a lavish space.
The lobster rolls are the star of the menu, with generous portions of fresh lobster meat served on a buttery roll.
The staff is attentive and knowledgeable about the menu, making for a pleasant dining experience.
Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Joe's Seafood is the perfect spot for a satisfying lobster roll.
2. Maple & Ash
Maple & Ash is an upscale steakhouse and seafood eatery that offers a variety of delicious dishes, including their famous lobster roll.
The lobster roll is made with fresh, succulent lobster meat that is perfectly seasoned and served on a buttery, toasted roll. The roll is accompanied by a side of crispy fries and a tangy coleslaw.
The meal is not cheap, but it is worth every penny for the quality of the food and the exceptional service.
The restaurant has a chic lounge area that is perfect for enjoying a cocktail or two before or after your meal. Maple & Ash is a must-visit spot for anyone looking for a luxurious dining experience.
3. Hugo's Frog Bar & Fish House
Hugo's Frog Bar & Fish House is an upscale seafood restaurant that is famous for its crab cakes, steaks, and lobster rolls.
The lobster rolls are presented in an interesting way and are packed with flavors. The oysters and shrimp are also fresh and delicious.
The service is hospitable, and the drinks are excellent. This is a great place to go for a date or to meet with friends.
The staff is professional and sweet, and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. If you are looking for a good seafood place in the area, Hugo's Frog Bar & Fish House is worth checking out.
4. RPM Seafood
RPM Seafood is a glitzy, upscale dining experience that offers craft cocktails and seafood-based fine dining.
The restaurant is located on the riverfront and has an elegant, dimly lit atmosphere.
The wait staff is attentive and professional, and the food is absolutely delicious. The lobster roll, in particular, is a standout dish that is prepared to perfection.
If you're looking for a high-end dining experience and exceptional seafood, RPM Seafood is the place to be.
5. Luke's Lobster City Hall
Luke's Lobster City Hall is a seafood restaurant that specializes in Maine-style lobster rolls.
The toasted buns and fresh lobster meat make for a delicious meal. The staff is friendly and provides fast service.
While the prices can be a bit high, the quality of the food is worth it. The restaurant also serves clam chowder, which is a great complement to the lobster rolls.
If you're in the mood for some delicious seafood, Luke's Lobster City Hall is definitely worth a visit.
6. The Fishguy Market & Wellfleet
The Fishguy Market & Wellfleet is a seafood restaurant and market that serves up a delicious lobster roll. The roll is packed with large, succulent chunks of lobster that are sure to satisfy any seafood lover's cravings.
While the market has a limited selection of fish, the quality is significantly higher than what you would find at a grocery store.
The cafe is good, but not outstanding, and the prices are a bit higher than average. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is clean and welcoming.
Keep in mind that the hours are limited, so plan accordingly. If you're looking for some of the best oysters and seafood in town, The Fishguy Market & Wellfleet is definitely worth a visit.
7. All Star Seafood and Sports
All Star Seafood and Sports is a fantastic spot for anyone looking for a great lobster roll.
The seafood is fresh and the lobster salad is packed with meat and just the right amount of mayo.
The atmosphere is fun and lively, making it a great place to grab lunch or dinner with friends.
The service is fast and friendly, and the prices are reasonable. If you're in the mood for seafood and sports, All Star Seafood and Sports is the place to be!
8. Catch 35
Catch 35 is a must-visit place for lobster roll lovers. The fresh seafood and impeccable service make for a wonderful dining experience.
The lobster tail is the standout dish and is cooked to perfection. The portions are on the smaller side, but the quality of the food makes up for it.
The location provides great views and the ambiance is perfect for a fine dining experience.
Make sure to make a reservation as it can get busy. Catch 35 is a top-notch seafood restaurant that should be on everyone's list.
9. Brown Bag Seafood Co
Brown Bag Seafood Co offers a unique twist on the classic lobster roll.
While the roll may be a bit pricey, the spices used in the dish give it a delicious and unique flavor.
The Parmesan flaked tots are also a standout dish, and the black iced tea is a refreshing beverage option.
With a variety of fresh seafood options and a casual atmosphere, Brown Bag Seafood Co is a great spot to satisfy your seafood cravings.
10. Lure Fishbar – Chicago
Lure Fishbar – Chicago is a popular spot for seafood lovers looking for a high-end dining experience.
While they offer a variety of dishes, their lobster roll is a standout item on the menu. The lobster is fresh and perfectly cooked, and the roll is toasted to perfection.
The seasoning is just right, and the presentation is impressive. The staff is knowledgeable and attentive, making for a seamless dining experience.
If you're in the mood for a delicious lobster roll, Lure Fishbar – Chicago is the place to go.
11. Fish Bar
Fish Bar is a small, casual seafood spot that serves sustainably sourced seafood in various forms. They specialize in lobster rolls, which are authentic and remind customers of ones they had in Maine.
The lobster is perfectly cooked, but the bun can be a bit dry and the slaw can overpower the meat.
The clam chowder is off the charts good and worth a try. The portions are not very big, but the fresh quality seafood and atmosphere make up for it.
Prices have gone up during COVID, but the food is delicious and worth it.
12. BIG & little's Restaurant
BIG & little's Restaurant is a casual counter-serve eatery that offers a variety of seafood and meat tacos, po' boys, burgers, and fries.
This place is a must-visit for lobster roll lovers. The lobster roll is made with fresh, quality seafood and is absolutely delicious.
The service is impeccable, and the staff is friendly and attentive. The prices are reasonable, making it an excellent value for money.
The atmosphere is casual, and the seating area is roomy. If you're in the mood for some great seafood, BIG & little's Restaurant is definitely worth checking out.
13. Two Fish Crab Shack
Looking for a place to get a delicious lobster roll in town without breaking the bank, then Two Fish Crab Shack is the place for you.
The staff is friendly and knowledgeable and will help guide you through their menu. The lobster sandwich is a must-try, and the bread is simply amazing. The seafood is fresh and cooked to perfection.
The atmosphere is casual and laid-back, and the restaurant is spacious and clean. The only downside is that drinks are not included in the meal and must be purchased separately.
Nonetheless, Two Fish Crab Shack is definitely worth a visit if you're in the mood for some scrumptious seafood.
