As a New Yorker living in Chicago, I’ve been on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in the city. I’m talking about a thin, crispy crust that’s slightly charred on the bottom, a tangy tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese that stretches for miles.
While there’s no shortage of pizza places in Chicago, finding a slice that rivals the best in the Big Apple can be a challenge.
But fear not, pizza lovers! After months of research and taste-testing, I’ve narrowed down the top contenders for the best New York style pizza in Chicago.
These places may not be in the heart of Little Italy or have a line out the door, but they bring the taste of New York to the Windy City.
Whether you’re a native New Yorker missing a taste of home or a Chicagoan looking to try something new, these pizza places are sure to satisfy your cravings.
So sit back, grab a slice (or two), and let’s dive into the best New York style pizza in Chicago.
Giordano's is a New York style pizza place that is known for their deep-dish pizza.
Their crust is thick and buttery and the cheese is heavy, making it a satisfying meal. The service is fast and friendly, and the atmosphere is inviting.
They also serve other classic Italian dishes and have a good selection of beer and wine.
If you're looking for a delicious deep-dish pizza, Giordano's is definitely worth a visit.
2. Pequod's Pizza
Pequod's Pizza serves up some delicious New York style pizza that won't disappoint.
The fluffy bread base and saucy toppings make for a tasty and satisfying slice.
The burnt cheese crust adds a nice crunch to each bite. The staff is friendly and the service is quick.
If you're looking for a great pizza spot, Pequod's is definitely worth checking out.
3. Jimmy's Pizza Cafe
Looking for the best New York-style pizza in town, then look no further than Jimmy's Pizza Cafe. This casual eatery offers a range of delicious pizza flavors by the pie or slice.
The thin crust is crispy on the edges and soft in the middle, perfect for folding. The toppings are balanced perfectly with the crust, making each bite a delight.
The beignets and coffee are also worth trying. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it a great spot for a casual date or hanging out with friends.
Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just love a good slice, Jimmy's Pizza Cafe is not to be missed.
4. Craft Pizza
Craft Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. Their New York style pizzas are simply delicious and made with fresh ingredients.
The crust is crispy and the sauce is just the right amount – not too much, not too little.
The staff is friendly and the service is fast. The restaurant has a casual atmosphere and a cool patio.
It's a great place to grab a slice or a whole pie with friends. BYOB is a plus. Craft Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you're in the mood for some tasty pizza.
5. Robert's Pizza and Dough Company
Robert's Pizza and Dough Company is a must-try for pizza lovers.
With a thin, crispy crust and an array of delicious toppings, their New York-style pizza is sure to impress.
The restaurant has a sleek, modern design and attentive service.
They also offer a variety of salads and seasonal cocktails to complement the pizza. Don't miss out on this artisanal pizza spot.
6. Big G's Pizza
Big G's Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers. Their New York style slices are prepared ahead of time and ready in minutes.
The menu offers a wide variety of toppings, including vegetarian options. The crust is crispy and the toppings go all the way to the edge.
The staff is friendly and the service is fast. The restaurant has ample seating space, making it a great spot to enjoy a slice or two.
Don't miss out on their beer-battered fries and exotic sodas. It's the perfect place for a late-night pizza craving.
7. Dante's Pizzeria
Dante's Pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza. The crust is solid and the slices are big, making it a satisfying meal.
They offer vegetarian meat and vegan cheese/meat options, catering to all dietary preferences.
The staff is friendly and they have daily specialty pizzas that are worth trying. The pizzas are large, so be prepared to take some home.
The decor is cool, adding to the overall experience. If you're looking for a great pizza spot, Dante's Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out.
8. Ranalli's Lincoln Park
Ranalli's Lincoln Park is a casual eatery that serves delicious New York style pizza and pub food. It has a big outdoor patio and a wrap-around bar inside.
The craft beer and cocktail selection is great, and the staff is super nice and attentive. The menu offers a variety of pizzas and appetizers, all of which are delicious.
The pizza is cracker-thin with plenty of sausage chunks and fresh mushrooms, but it would have been better with more cheese. The hot honey pizza is amazing and the watermelon salad is a great pair.
The mozzarella sticks are highly recommended. The place is dog-friendly, and the staff quickly helped a customer who had a medical emergency. Ranalli's Lincoln Park is a true neighborhood gem that offers a fun atmosphere and great food.
9. Gigio's Pizzeria
Gigio's Pizzeria is a no-frills pizza joint serving up delicious New York-style pizza by the pie or slice.
The pizza is thin, crispy, and has a great cheese-crust-topping ratio.
The staff is friendly and helpful, making it a great spot for a quick bite or a late-night snack.
The prices are reasonable, and the portions are generous. If you're looking for a solid spot for pizza, Gigio's Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out.
10. Bacci Pizzeria
Bacci Pizzeria serves authentic New York-style pizza with a nice crispy crust and great flavors.
The pizza slices are huge, making it a great option for a cheap lunch. The staff is friendly and professional, creating a comfortable atmosphere.
The wait time is short, and the food is hot and fresh. The restaurant also serves pasta, burgers, sandwiches, and more.
Perfect for a casual meal, Bacci Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers.